Present
at the meeting were Marc A. Schuckit, Susan Tapert, and
Marianne Guschwan (Director and Associate Directors);
Marcy Gregg (Administrator); Second-Year Scholars Gavin
Bart, Larry Gray, and Anika Alvanzo; First-Year Scholars
Tim Lineberry, Krishna Balachandra, Maritza Lagos, and
Leslie Buckley; along with guests Ryan Trim, Shannon
Robinson, and Steve Groban.
I.
Wednesday evening, April 30th
The
meeting began at 6:30 p.m. through an introduction of
the scholars, guests, and spouses.
Dr. Schuckit took the opportunity of reviewing some of
his recent AMSP activities, reminded the participants of
the goals over the next three days, and to work through
some of the details of the agenda.
The group continued the discussion over a working dinner
at the hotel.
II. Thursday, May 1st
The
morning=s
activities began with a working breakfast where
Marc Schuckit shared details of his AMSP-based
activities while on sabbatical in
South Africa.
His major task was to work with the two medical
schools in
Cape Town (Stellenbosch
and
Cape Town
University),
a local research center, and about five regional
hospitals in the area to enhance education about
research regarding alcohol and drugs.
This included lectures to medical students, two
single-day seminars about how to lecture and develop
careers, a review of recent developments in alcohol and
drugs, and clinically-oriented seminars at five local
hospitals, as well as the medical school.
Dr. Schuckit worked closely with young faculty
members at all of the institutions with the goal of
helping them with their clinically-oriented research
projects focusing on the relationships between alcohol
and drugs on the one hand, and schizophrenia, anxiety,
and depressive disorders on the other.
Additional outreach included helping young
faculty members looking at aspects of the fetal alcohol
syndrome, epidemiology of alcohol use, issues related to
methamphetamine problems in
South Africa,
prevention efforts, and studies of outreach and
prevention regarding substance-related conditions.
The
next morning session was also delivered by Dr.
Schuckit who presented his lecture on
AHow to Develop a
Lecture,@
presenting modifications regarding using the same
approach for developing a research paper, a grant, a
presentation at Grand Rounds, etc.
Here, Junior Scholars were asked for suggestions
about how the presentations might have been modified to
have helped them better prepare the lectures they were
about to develop. The first time they had heard this
presentation they were planning for their own
presentations, but had not yet begun to work on them, so
they had a different perspective during this session.
The
major points made were then emphasized through a
presentation of An Overview of Genetic and Environmental
Influences in Alcoholism, a full lecture delivered by
Dr. Schuckit. The group
discussed how the presentation affected their
understanding of the process of developing materials in
a systematic data-based way, as well as underscoring
some of the aspects of appropriate slides and delivery.
Dr. Larry Gray
of the Department of Pediatrics at the University of
Chicago Pritzker School of Medicine, Comer Children’s
Hospital next presented his accomplishments at his
University. Dr. Gray continues
to represent the need for alcohol and substance use
education at the
University of
Chicago
with his participation in the Pritzker Initiative, which
is a medical school-wide curriculum redesign that began
in 2008. Dr. Gray will participate
in two committee meetings during his final phase of AMSP.
In addition, he has successfully completed the
Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics fellowship
training in “How to Give a Lecture.”
The first DBP fellow completed this training and
recently demonstrated her increased lecture
effectiveness at a national meeting in March 2008.
Finally, Dr. Gray has benefited by the mentoring
afforded by the AMSP experience, traveled to meet a
senior researcher in his field, and was invited to
prepare a chapter reviewing the contribution of ADHD to
the development of substance use disorders across the
developmental spectrum.
Subsequently, Dr. Gavin Bart of the Department of
Medicine at the University of Minnesota Medical School
reviewed his accomplishments over the prior months at
that Institution. Dr. Bart
continues to provide substance use disorder education at
all levels. Since the last AMSP
meeting he has recruited another addiction medicine
faculty to his division. This has
allowed increased presence of addiction specialists on
the general medicine wards. The
medical school internal medicine clerkship now has three
hours of substance use disorder lectures.
One third of the
University of
Minnesota
medical students are exposed to these lectures.
It remains difficult to increase the four hours
of substance use disorder education in the first two
years of the medical school curriculum.
At the residency level, Dr. Bart continues to
host internal medicine interns during their behavioral
medicine rotation and he coordinates the psychiatry
residents’ 16-hour rotations available at the HCMC
addiction medicine program. Outside
of medicine, Dr. Bart has provided lectures to the
Minnesota House of Representatives Committee on Health
and Human Services, the Minnesota Department of Human
Services managers meeting, social work departments, and
the Minnesota Bar Association. He
has also designed a full-day symposium on
pharmacotherapy for substance dependence disorders for
the fall 2008 meeting of the Minnesota Association for
Resources in Recovery and Chemical Health.
This conference is attended by 1000 alcohol and
drug counselors throughout
Minnesota.
Next, Dr. Shannon Robinson, a clinician, scholar,
and teacher in the Department of Psychiatry at
UCSD
Medical
School
and San Diego VA Medical Center reviewed some of her
work based on skills learned through her participation
as a guest at meetings of AMSP.
Shannon updated how
activities now include a rotation of pain fellows on the
Alcohol and Drug Treatment Program, and an expansion of
a rotation of Navy psychiatry residents on her teaching
unit, with each of these complementing the ongoing
efforts in reaching out and teaching about alcohol and
drugs. Medical students also rotate
for three weeks with two-to-three students per session,
spending full time on the Alcohol and Drug Treatment
Program, second-year residents rotate for two months,
and fourth-year psychiatric residents rotate for six
months to a year.
Shannon shared a
manualized group treatment approach regarding helping
patients to handle pain syndromes, which she developed
along with other members of the faculty at UCSD.
The
group next turned to a working lunch during which
issues related to career development were discussed.
This session included questions relating to the
optimal implementation of training awards from the
National Institutes of Health (K-Awards); mechanisms for
keeping up clinical service obligations while funded by
training awards; decision processes required for
planning the continuation of research and/or clinical
obligations after training awards have ended; the
challenges of setting aside time to read the literature,
as well as to write papers; and setting overall
priorities in use of time.
Following lunch, First-Year Scholar,
Krishna Balachandra,
presented his newly-developed lecture on the Integration
of Treatment of Co-occurring Psychiatric and Substance
Use Disorders. This was an
excellent effort, and few changes will be required
before this presentation can be loaded onto the AMSP
website for use by teachers and scholars at other
universities. The lecture style,
clarity of slides, and flow of logic demonstrated
through this lecture were exemplary.
The
meeting adjourned at 2:30 in the afternoon with the
scholars and their families on their own for the
evening.
III. Friday, May 2nd
The
group convened at 8:00 a.m. over a working breakfast
with the opportunity of hearing the lecture by
Second-Year Scholar, Gavin Bart regarding the
Recognition and Treatment of Obesity.
This was a fine and effective lecture that
generated a lively discussion regarding issues centering
on slides, the application of the information to a range
of audiences, and many compliments on the fine delivery
style. Dr. Schuckit emphasized that
with only a modest amount of work, this lecture could be
easily modified for another audience.
He asked Dr. Bart to re-present a similar lecture
on Saturday, but this time limiting himself to 20
minutes and focusing on a group of professors at a
university who are taking part in a weight reduction
program.
Next, Dr. Krishna
Balachandra presented his report from the
University of
Western Ontario.
Dr. Balachandra continues his commitment to
teaching undergraduate, post-graduate, and psychiatrists
regarding substance use disorders (SUD). He completed
his survey of the undergraduate medical curriculum to
determine the amount of time devoted to substance use
disorders, and received acknowledgment from his Dean and
Chair of the Department of Psychiatry for his
participation in the Alcohol Medical Scholars Program.
He was able to introduce a movie related to substance
abuse themes into the medical student psychiatry movie
night, and continues to give the SUD and brief
motivational intervention lectures. Dr. Balachandra’s
current project involves a collaborative effort with the
Information Technology Resource Centre at his university
to develop case-based learning for medical students. At
the post-graduate level, he lectures to final-year
residents on SUDs as part of their preparation for
taking the national board examinations in psychiatry, as
part of a national review course supported by the
University of Western Ontario. He was invited by
psychiatry residents to give an additional lecture on
toxidromes. Dr. Balachandra also contributes to
educating psychiatrists by being part of the faculty
providing a Fundamentals of Addictions course at the
Canadian Psychiatric Association annual meeting. Later
this year, he will transition from the
University of
Western Ontario
to the
University of
Alberta.
Following this presentation, First-Year Scholar, Dr.
Timothy Lineberry from the Mayo Clinic College of
Medicine presented his lecture on Substance Use
Disorders and Suicide. This was
a well-focused lecture, highly appropriate for the
medical student audience to which it was aimed, and
delivered in an excellent and effective style.
The group discussed various details regarding
specific issues raised, as well as well as the slides,
and Dr. Lineberry was encouraged to polish off minor
remaining details be certain that the lecture was loaded
on the AMSP Website within the next month.
First-Year Scholar Dr. Leslie Buckley of the University
of Toronto next presented her activities at her
University.
She began by meeting with the Dean of the
Medical
School
to discuss what is currently offered medical students
regarding alcohol and drug education, and how things
might be improved. Through these
discussions, she became interested in optimal teaching
styles and what might be done to help her University
(and the field in general) enhance education through an
interactive process. In addition,
she interacts with medical students in their first two
years, and is attempting to expand education to medical
students in their third and fourth year, adding a
three-hour lecture to their ongoing activities.
Dr. Buckley helped develop an Addiction
Psychiatry Education Committee to outline curriculum
models for each year, and to try to initiate new ways of
enhancing the delivery of the materials being developed.
Anika Alvanzo
of the
Virginia
Commonwealth
University
Medical
Center
next presented her lecture on Intimate Partner
Violence and the Role of Alcohol and Drugs.
This, too, was a fine lecture and was well
delivered, with the slides contributing effectively to
the presentation. After a discussion
of several details, Dr. Schuckit emphasized how similar
material could be delivered to yet another audience
using a totally different time frame for presentation.
Dr. Alvanzo agreed to return to her lecture the
following day but now focusing on physicians about to
begin their new jobs in Emergency Departments, where she
was only given 10 minutes to cover what she felt was the
key material. The group discussed
some of the approaches that might be used, and looked
forward to Dr. Alvanzo=s
subsequent presentation.
The
next topic was the plans for the AMSP reunion to be
held in conjunction with the Research Society on
Alcoholism meeting in
San Diego
beginning Saturday, June 20th.
The AMSP meeting, therefore, could begin the Wednesday
before RSA (June 17, 2009), or might be slated to begin
Wednesday at RSA closes (the evening of June 24th).
In addition to the usual First and Second-Year
Scholars as participants in this meeting, a letter will
be sent to all graduates of AMSP inviting them to
participate as part of the AMSP audience and discussion
sessions themselves. For those
graduates interested in attending, but who do not have
financial resources to help them come to San Diego, as
many as AMSP can afford will be invited to attend at our
expense. The RSA meeting will also
be used as an opportunity to highlight activities of
AMSP. One idea is to propose an RSA
roundtable of as many appropriate graduates as possible
to discuss various approaches for enhancing alcohol and
drug education in medical school settings.
A second possibility is to highlight the research
developments of several (up to four) scholars who have
graduated from our program and who have gone onto
develop a successful research careers as a seminar at
the RSA. A third proposal is to make
a poster for one of the poster sessions at RSA, a step
that can help with appropriate recruitment in the
future.
The
noontime career development discussion then
focused on various roles for researchers and clinical
scholars at medical schools; discussions of the
development of DSM-V; assets and liabilities and
appropriate timing for Junior Scholars to begin to ask
to serve on national committees and review groups; and
problems in clinical practice with the application of
careful diagnosis to help guide treatments, as well as
thoughts on what can be done to improve the situation.
Following lunch, Dr.
Anika Alvanzo presented the educational efforts she was
able to develop at
Virginia
Commonwealth
University
Medical
Center.
She has initiated a lunch-time Addiction Seminar
Series. Prior to the series she had
the opportunity to meet with Dr. Ike Wood, who was at
the time Associate Dean of Student Affairs and has since
been appointed as Dean of Undergraduate Education.
He thought the groups were a good idea and asked
for a copy of the documentary series for potential use
in other settings. Dr. Alvanzo was
happy to provide him with an extra copy of the
documentary. The Addiction Seminar
Series began this semester, were held monthly from noon
to 1:00 p.m., with light refreshments being provided.
They were marketed specifically to the first- and
second-year medical students but were open to all
medical students. The series were
co-facilitated by Dr. Michael Weaver, Director of the
Substance Abuse Consult Service at VCU.
The last seminar was scheduled for the same week
that Dr. Weaver was lecturing on substance use disorders
to the M2 medical students. Portions
of the HBO documentary, “Addiction,” were shown and an
informal discussion followed. The
seminars were well received by the students who
participated. As Dr. Alvanzo will be
leaving VCU, she has left a copy of the documentary
series with Dr. Weaver in hopes that he or one of his
colleagues would be interested in continuing the seminar
series.
As
stated above, Dr. Alvanzo will be leaving VCU and will
be joining the faculty at
Johns
Hopkins
University.
She has taken a position as the Medical Director
of the Broadway Program, an intensive outpatient
substance use disorder treatment program, located on the
downtown campus. In addition, she
will continue her research on psychological trauma and
substance use. Dr. Alvanzo is the
recipient of a 2008 College on Problems of Drug
Dependence Travel Award and has a manuscript that will
be published in Substance Use and Misuse.
Subsequently, First-Year Scholar Maritza Lagos of
Michigan
State
University
presented her accomplishments at her University.
Her plan was reviewed and approved by Michael R.
Liepman, MD, Director of Research & Clinical Professor,
Dept. of Psychiatry,
Michigan State
University/Kalamazoo
Center for Medical Studies. These
past six months she used a noon meeting to describe AMSP
and her role as a scholar and showed the residents and
attendings the
www.alcoholmedicalscholar.org. Web page and
encouraged them to use it for educational purposes.
In this midst of this process she became the
Psychiatry Clerkship Director where she implemented the
lecture on Substance Use Disorders with emphasis on
alcohol abuse and dependence for the third-year medical
students. In concert with Dr.
Liepman, she has also developed and delivered lectures
on substance use disorders for the new residents
starting in Psychiatry. Also, the
second-year residents have borrowed the AMSP lectures to
prepare topics for their own use.
The goal is that these topics will be initially
discussed with the clinical supervisor and then
delivered to the medical students during the week of
Substance Use Disorders rotation.
The hope is that the residents will learn by teaching
and the medical students will benefit by reviewing these
lectures on an individual basis.
The
final activity on Friday afternoon ended with the
presentation by Dr. Timothy Lineberry regarding
alcohol and drug education at the
Mayo
Clinic
College
of Medicine. Dr. Lineberry
reported on progress made at Mayo Clinic in
Rochester,
MN.
The observed clinical skills examination case
this year will involve a patient with a substance use
disorder. He has also surveyed other
residency and fellowship programs in the Mayo Graduate
School of Medical Education regarding their coverage of
alcohol and addictive disorders.
There is strong interest in these programs for
increasing the amount of training provided.
The second-year psychopathology course will
continue with strong focus on substance dependence.
Dr. Lineberry is also Co-Chair of an inaugural
Continuing Medical Education (CME) course sponsored by
the Mayo School of CME, “Acute Care Psychiatry,” in
Chicago,
October 2008. This course will weave
alcohol abuse, dependence, and other substance use
disorders into the educational blocks.
He also noted continuing progress academically
and pointed out the first-author publication in
Schizophrenia Research of a medical student, Rebecca
Capasso (currently training psychiatry at NYU), whom he
has mentored since the last AMSP meeting.
The
group then adjourned after making plans for the working
dinner (with spouses) to be held that evening.
IV. Saturday, May 3rd
This
last day of the AMSP meeting began with the
presentation by First-Year Scholar, Dr. Maritz Lagos of
her lecture focusing on the Recognition and Treatment of
Opioid Dependence. This was an
excellent lecture, with very appropriate slides.
There were suggestions from the group regarding
expanding the information relating to treatment issues,
and making room for this within the time frame of the
presentation by decreasing some of the data offered on
brain mechanisms of opiate effects.
Dr. Lagos will incorporate these changes in modifying
her lecture and offer the final version within a month.
All scholars were impressed with the quality of
the work.
Dr. Leslie Buckley, a First-Year Scholar
from the
University of
Toronto,
next presented an early version of her lecture
focusing on Medical Student Education.
The core of the work involved incorporating
data-based educational tools into the medical school
curriculum, and she used education on substance use
disorders as the example. The
delivery was excellent, the material offered of great
use to medical educators, and the slides covered
important information. Suggestions
were made regarding the possibility of relating more
directly material already posted on our website by Dr.
Gail Rose (separate topics but a cross reference would
be useful), as well as some additional work to clarify
the slides.
Dr. Larry Gray of
The
University of
Chicago Comer Children’s
Hospital next addressed the challenge given to him by
Dr. Schuckit to take his original lecture on
Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) and
modify it to a 30-minute presentation focusing on
teachers for exceptional children.
This was a beautiful demonstration of how a
longer lecture developed for one audience can be
modified for another. The discussion
then focused on what Dr. Gray would do if he only had 10
minutes; only five minutes; etc. The
answer rests with being able to focus on the major
points that might be appropriate to be made during that
period of time.
Our
final presentations of the morning were the shortened
version of the Obesity Lecture originally developed
by Gavin Bart, as well as the shortened
lecture by Dr. Anika Alvanzo. As
with Dr. Gary, these were superb demonstrations of how
slides can be modified for specific audiences; the areas
of emphasis can be identified; and a basic lecture once
developed can be delivered to a variety of audiences
using a range of time frames.
Additional topics were then reviewed toward the end of
the morning=s
session:
1.
Marcy Gregg presented an update on
developments for the AMSP Web site.
March and April this year demonstrated the
largest number of visits ever observed at our website,
and throughout the year the number of downloads and the
time spent on our site were remarkably higher than those
ever seen in the past. An example is
the fact that visitors spent 334 hours per month this
past year, compared to 227 hours per month in the prior
year. Several suggestions were made
regarding the additional improvements that can be added
to the website including a brochure on motivational
interviewing (to be done by Dr. Guschwan), and the
possibility of adding a video of the lecture on How to
Give a Lecture.
2.
The next meeting of AMSP will begin on October
15, 2008. Marcy Gregg will look
into the possibility of booking the Surf and Sand Hotel
in
Laguna Beach.
3.
The Spring 2009 AMSP meeting will be in
Del Mar,
California (a suburb of
San Diego)
beginning on Wednesday, June 24th.
4.
The next Conference Call for AMSP will take
place on July 10, 2008 at noon (San
Diego time - 3:00 p.m. East Coast
time). All First- and
Second-Year Scholars will need to attend this one-hour
conference call to wrap up our year.
5.
First-Year Scholars are reminded that all
lectures must be in the
San Diego
office by June 2, 2008 to be loaded on the Web site.
The
group adjourned at 12:15 p.m., with all participants
wished a safe and swift return home.
Marc
A. Schuckit, M.D.