Present at the meeting were Dr. Marc A.
Schuckit (Director), Junior Scholars: Donna Londino, Jean-Joel
Villier, Christopher Welsh, Lauren Williams; Senior Scholars:
Laura Bierut, Marianne Guschwan; Vania Modesto-Lowe, Susan
Tapert; and Karen Trocki, RSA Representative,
as
well as Ulrich Preuss and Valentin Isacescu (guests).
I.
Wednesday, May 16th.
The participants assembled at the Surf
and Sand Hotel in Laguna on Wednesday afternoon.
We met together for a social hour at 7:00 p.m.,
followed by a pleasant dinner (with a bit of work) at the
hotel. The tentative agenda for the
subsequent two-and-a-half days was briefly discussed, as was
the location for the meeting the next morning.
II.
Thursday, May 17th.
The meeting began at 8:00 a.m. in the
Dolphin Room for a working breakfast and beginning of the
meeting.
The first order of business was the
introduction of the two guests and a brief review of the
potential agenda. Some modifications were
made, and the meeting began.
Marianne Guschwan presented the
progress made during her Sr. Scholar year at NYU.
Marianne shared progress on a variety of fronts.
These included: successful implementation of a
mini‑rotation of medical students on the detoxification unit
with new students every six weeks; identification of a medical
student who is willing to begin to develop a DOC program;
successful implementation of a one‑and‑a‑half hour workshop
(carried out jointly with Susan Tapert) at the American
Academy of Addiction Psychiatry where 30‑to‑40 participants
learned how to improve their teaching techniques in substance
use disorders and psychiatric conditions; repetition of the
same workshop (again for approximately 40 people) at the
annual American Psychiatric Association meeting; a workshop
carried out at the American Psychiatric Association on career
development for young faculty members, with Marianne serving
as co‑chair; implementation of a program working with fellows
in substance use disorders at NYU regarding the development of
teaching techniques; assumption of the chairmanship of the
American Psychiatric Association Committee on Treatment
Services for Substance Use Disorders; development and
implementation of a course on substance use disorders for
nursing staff at NYU hospitals; expansion of information on
substance use disorders and lecturing techniques to
psychiatric residents at NYU; establishment of an ongoing
working relationship with the Associate Director of Training
and Education for the Division of Alcoholism and Drug Abuse,
Dr. Petros Levounis; continuing work with the Director of
Medical Student Education for Psychiatry, Dr. Myrl Manley, to
ensure that education about substance use disorders is
appropriately included in the first and second year curricula
which is being revised; being appointed Associate Director of
the Division of Alcoholism and Drug Abuse, serving as
assistant to Dr. Marc Galanter; being appointed Director of
the Substance Abuse Referral Program thereby reaching out to
all other services at Bellevue Hospital.
Dr. Guschwan continues to work at setting up additional
programs including: developing an overview of alcohol and drug
education offered between the first year of medical school
through addiction fellowship at NYU; attempts to expand the
medical students=
exposure to AA (although this is being met with a fair amount
of resistance); working with Dr. Levounis in developing a
four‑week elective on the dual diagnosis and detox units, as
well as outpatient programs for second‑year residents; and the
implementation of career and movie night programs that will
incorporate substance use disorders.
The next issue involved a discussion of
career development for first-and-second year scholars.
The discussion focused on criteria for deciding whether
to take on a requested task. Dr. Schuckit=s
advice was to carefully think through why one might say yes:
because it's something that would be fun; it would be good for
advancing your career; it's an inherent part of the job; it
would make somebody with power over you very angry if you said
no; and etc. The key point was that there
can be many reasons for taking on a task, and it is important
to make the decision after having thought through why the
effort would be worthwhile. Another
related career development issue was how to decide about
salary, and the most appropriate approach to negotiating.
Marc Schuckit then presented an update
on the lecture "How to Give a Lecture".
A brief background review was offered relating to
philosophy, preparation, and development of slides.
Because this is an area for which a great deal of work
has been done by all of the Junior Scholars over the prior six
months, and reflecting the fact that each person was about to
present a lecture, the focus of the material was on the
presentation itself. This lecture has been
written up by Marianne Guschwan and Susan Tapert, placed on
the website by Susan Tapert and is available to everyone.
Susan Tapert then demonstrated her
lecture on
ANeurocognitive Correlates of Substance Use Disorders
in Adolescents.@
It was emphasized that the scholars should pay closest
attention to the lecture organization, appropriateness of
slides, and delivery as examples of materials presented in
Marc Schuckit's prior lecture. This was an
example of a data-oriented lecture that was being developed
for presentation at a scientific meeting.
Donna Londino offered an overview of
the progress made over the prior six months at the Medical
College of Georgia. Donna has
accomplished a great deal in this relatively short period of
time including: she has become the Coordinator for
Psychiatry for First-Year Medical Student Education,
fighting to retain Psychiatry as a separate entity within that
year and incorporating as much relevant material for substance
use disorders as possible; she has spent a great deal of time
updating her knowledge and skills regarding substance use
disorders in general, as she had joined AMSP as an expert in
adolescent and child psychiatry without much background in
alcohol and drugs; Donna has become a central contact person
regarding substance use disorder issues at her medical center;
she has developed contacts with the group entitled Students
for Community Involvement, and has also worked with nursing
education groups regarding substance-related issues; Donna
participated in a two-hour evening internet chat room on
substance-related problems, and has used some of the skills
she has acquired as part of AMSP to feel more comfortable
during a television appearance; under her direction, the
Medical College of Georgia continues to have Friday lunches
regarding psychiatric issues, with one per month devoted to
substance use disorders, and she is incorporating issues
related to substance problems in the once per month movie
club; Donna has joined the neurobiology lecture series for
PGY2 residents by adding information on prenatal exposure to
substances of abuse and consequent childhood behavioral
problems; she is now part of a grant that is likely to be
funded by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation regarding HIV,
including the role of substance dependence; and Donna is
participating in the early stages of research projects.
Over the next six months (prior to the Fall, 2001 AMSP
meeting), Donna hopes to: implement a clinical elective on
substance use disorders incorporating adolescent and adult
psychiatry; work to optimize the amount of information on
substance use disorders in the Year One of medical school
education; and work to expand treatment offered for
substance-related problems in the adolescent psychiatric
program.
The morning progressed with the
demonstration of a lecture entitled
ASubstance Use Disorders in African-Americans@
by Jean-Joel Villier. Jean-Joel
had spent a great deal of his efforts optimizing the
organization of the lecture and the slide copy.
He is in the process of expanding the specific amounts
of data offered around the lecture outline items, and was
given a number of suggestions regarding organization,
appropriate sensitivity to concerns of the audience, the need
to markedly expand the information offered on dependence (as
distinct from use patterns); and how to optimize delivery.
He will work with Karen Trocki on the next draft.
Finally, before adjourning, Marc
Schuckit discussed his plans to modify the directions given to
potential AMSP scholars. These include
making it clear that no first-year scholars should join the
program unless they are certain they can participate fully in
both face-to-face meetings (arriving with an appropriate
amount of time before the 6:00 p.m. Wednesday start time and
not leaving prior to noon on the Saturday), participate in the
conference calls, create lecture material suitable for
presentation by December 31st following the first meeting; and
so on. The current first-year scholars
were told that they must consider the following before
deciding whether they would participate as a Senior Scholar,
including: the need to fully attend both meetings; participate
in conference calls; present at least one lecture as a
demonstration to Junior Scholars; and take on a mentorship
role with an assigned Junior Scholar throughout the year.
Scholars were invited to make suggestions regarding
these issues.
The meeting adjourned at approximately
2:30 p.m. with participants to reassemble at 7:00 p.m. for
dinner.
III.
Friday, May 18th.
The morning began with a review of the
day's agenda.
Vania Modesto-Lowe then demonstrated
her lecture on
AIs there a Role for Medications in the Treatment of
Alcohol Dependence?@.
The emphasis was placed on demonstrating the most
appropriate use of slides, as well as the importance of
focusing on flow of logic. This was a
useful demonstration of a very effective lecture, and one that
highlighted many of the issues relevant to the optimal
presentation technique.
Susan Tapert then handed out information
regarding the AMSP website. We were
all pleased with the level of use the website demonstrated,
exemplified by an average of 44 hits per day in May of
2001. Most of the individuals seemed to
have sought out the AMSP website directly, while a substantial
minority found their way to us through the connections to the
websites at the Research Society on Alcoholism and the
National Institute of Drug Abuse. The
hook-up via the National Institute of Alcohol Abuse and
Alcoholism website is soon to be implemented.
Susan's review of the days in the past year when
activity was at its highest on the website demonstrated that
the series of lectures offered at various meetings by AMSP
scholars are having a major impact on how people view and use
the website itself.
Our discussion next turned to the
progress made in developing copyright for materials listed on
the website. The major issue here is
that we want to preserve the website for everyone to use for
free, and therefore must take steps to be certain that no one
takes material from the website, copyrights it, and then
charges for its use. We have two potential
avenues to pursue, one which would copyright each specific
lecture, and the other which would utilize the website as a
newsletter/periodical which is updated every several months.
Susan and Marcy will look into the best way for us to
go and then proceed.
Susan Tapert next presented the
overview of progress made at UCSD. The
only "permanent" AMSP site is San Diego, and therefore, the
progress made each six months has to be looked at from the
standpoint of the long-term commitment of UCSD staff.
In the interim since the prior AMSP meeting, Susan once
again offered an elective on substance use disorders for first
and second year medical students. There
was enthusiastic support, although a smaller number of
participants than had been hoped. The
feedback from the students has been excellent.
Susan and Marc Schuckit are discussing ways of using a
flyer to medical students, reaching out to the UCSD division
of DOC, and other mechanisms to optimize participation in the
future. Susan next handed out an overview
of the alcohol and drug education activities at UCSD from
first-year medical students through fellows.
The UCSD scholars are working with the Doctors Ought to
Care (DOC) program, and Susan has met with the Associate Dean
assigned to DOC, Dr. Covelle. Finally, the
UCSD group shared the handout used at the American Psychiatric
Association meeting where the course on How to Give a Lecture
was held under the direction of both Susan and Marianne
Guschwan, and participants were informed that additional
information and slide copy could be obtained from the AMSP
website.
Next, Lauren Williams presented her
lecture on the
AFetal Alcohol Syndrome (FAS): An Overview.@
This was an excellent overview of the topic developed
by a Junior Scholar, and it was felt with a small amount of
work would be appropriate for loading on the website.
All junior scholars were reminded that
changes in the lecture outline, updates and references, and
alterations and slides should be completed by July 1, 2001 at
which time they will be loaded on the website.
The Washington University update was
next offered by Senior Scholar, Laura Bierut.
Laura's review was important for a particular reason:
she emphasized the fact that even scholars who have a prior
track record in research or substance use disorders can gain a
great deal from AMSP. Over the prior six
months, the accomplishments at Washington University included
the continuation and solidification of the second-year medical
student lecture series which now has more information about
substance use disorders and for which the mandatory attendance
at AA meetings has received excellent reviews by students.
Laura continues to participate in the curriculum reform
efforts at Washington University, and her presence there has
allowed her to push for the importance of substance use
disorders information as part of the core curriculum.
Her efforts have resulted in a representation of
substance use disorders in the now fully-implemented
first-year revision which had been piloted by Laura.
An important development is that through her activities
on AMSP she has gained enhanced visibility at Washington
University and is now turned to by the Dean, clinicians, and
students when issues relating to substance use disorders
arise. A new program is now being offered
to third-year residents and involves practice guidelines on
identification and treatment of substance use disorders, and
Laura has successfully implemented alcohol education as part
of a continuing medical education internal medicine board
review course. As a result of her
interactions on AMSP, she has also implemented a course on How
to Teach which is offered to medical students and for which
substance use disorders is one of the topics used.
Finally, Laura was able to offer some advice regarding
consideration of whether AMSP is useful as a two-year program.
She felt that the gains made at Washington University
during Year One would have been likely to have disappeared had
she not had the continuing support of the AMSP group in the
second year, as well as the knowledge that she was going to be
reporting every three-to-six months to us.
As with most institutions, Laura feels that once something can
be placed into the curriculum and then continued into its
second year, it is very likely to develop an inertia of its
own that markedly enhances the probability of its continuation
in years to come.
The morning's agenda then turned to a
discussion of the new AMSP Junior Scholars scheduled to
begin in August. Marc shared some
thoughts on the criteria used to select individuals for AMSP,
and presented the names of the four individuals selected to
begin. The fifth potential candidate, an
individual from Columbia University, was also discussed with
input from the scholars that this individual did appear to be
appropriate for the group. Marc will carry
out further conversations with him and make a decision soon
regarding offering the fifth position.
Scholars were asked to keep their eye open regarding any
individual who might appear outstanding for a sixth position.
However, unless someone is identified for
whom this year would be the only year appropriate, Marc would
prefer the sixth position to be used to support meeting
attendance by two substance use disorders fellows who are
currently working at UCSD to allow them to gain additional
information on optimal teaching techniques they might be able
to carry back with them to Germany. This
is consistent with the goal of AMSP in developing a cadre of
lectures on the website that will be useful world-wide.
Marc Schuckit then carried out a brief
discussion of how to review articles for journals.
Scholars will be sent one or more manuscripts for mock
reviews during their tenure.
Regarding career development, a brief
discussion ensued regarding a career development issue of
optimal approaches for clinical supervision.
Marc shared the guidelines that, as with a lecture, it
is important to know exactly what it is you hope to
accomplish, focus on the period of time (for example, once a
week for a month) during which the supervision will occur, and
adapt the approach to that which will be most likely to be
successfully accepted by the students.
Marc gave examples of clinical supervision sessions he is
currently carrying out with medical students and psychiatric
residents.
In the final formal presentation of the
day, the Junior Scholar, Donna Londino presented her
overview and lecture on
A Substance Use Disorders and the Family.@
Once again, this was an excellent lecture that will be
a useful addition to the website with only a moderate amount
of additional work.
Jean-Joel Villier then presented the
accomplishments made over the last six months at Howard
University. Jean-Joel has established
a strong and continuing working relationship with the Chief of
Substance Use Disorders at Howard, Dr. Gullatte.
She has assigned him many of the lectures relating to
substance use disorders at Howard University, and he has
incorporated into the curriculum AMSP lectures on Medical
Consequences of Alcoholism, the Introduction to Substance Use
Disorders and Categories of Drugs of Abuse, and Pharmacology.
In addition, Dr. Villier has participated in Grand
Rounds. Similar to Dr. Bierut and Dr.
Londino, Jean-Joel notes that he is now becoming recognized as
a contact person regarding substance use disorders problems
and optimizing sharing of information at his university.
In this role he has established a lecture on substance
use disorders for psychiatric residents, and has also produced
lectures for nursing and physician assistant students.
He is most fortunate that DOC has a strong tradition at
Howard, and he has joined their efforts, accompanying the
students on their visits to two high schools in an effort to
determine how he might best help them with their outreach to
young people. Over the upcoming six
months, Dr. Villier hopes to gather more information on
cataloging what is offered as part of the curriculum at Howard
relating to alcohol and other substance use disorders, to
consider implementing the elective on alcoholism and other
drug problems (using as a template the elective at UCSD which
is posted on the AMSP website), and hopes to begin to work
with internal medicine and Ob-Gyn in order to deliver AMSP-based
lectures on the fetal alcohol syndrome and medical
consequences of alcoholism. As his lecture
on substance use disorders in African-American progresses, he
plans to have a slot given to him in the Department of
Psychiatry Grand Rounds. An additional
suggestion is the possibility that Dr. Villier take advantage
of the fact that he is in the Washington DC area to see if his
medical school could facilitate any outreach between AMSP and
the Congress, especially the Black Caucus.
Finally, Vania Modesto-Lowe, a Senior
Scholar, reviewed the accomplishments at the University of
Connecticut over the prior six months.
These have included the incorporation of four lectures on
substance use disorders to third-year medical students
rotating through psychiatry at their major teaching hospital,
with the expansion of these efforts to students rotating
through psychiatry at other University of Connecticut Medical
School facilities as of July, 2001.
Furthermore, she has incorporated a fellow studying substance
use disorders into the lecture series, a step that will
hopefully help this individual to also utilize AMSP material
to facilitate the further development of his or her career.
Dr. Modesto-Lowe has delivered her lecture on the role
of medications in the treatment of alcoholism to psychiatric
residents at the University of Connecticut, is now part of the
first-year introductory (crash) course given to
psychiatrists---focusing her lecture on substance use
problems, and is working on the development of an addictions
rotation for PGY3 residents. A wonderful
development is that Dr. Modesto-Lowe has just been named
Director of the University of Connecticut Fellowship for
Substance Use Disorders. In addition
to all of these activities, Dr. Modesto-Lowe continues to
carry out lectures in the community.
The day=s
activities ended with a wonderful and thoughtful presentation
of gifts and thanks to Marcy Gregg for all of her wonderful
work in facilitating our AMSP meetings.
Marc Schuckit also bashfully accepted a lovely gift and card.
IV.
Saturday, May 19th.
The morning began with some reflections
on the fact that Senior Scholars will be rotating off.
Everyone expressed a strong desire to maintain an
ongoing relationship which will include: all graduates
will be kept on the e-mail and mailing lists so they know how
things are progressing; Marcy and Marc will notify graduates
(as well as current scholars) when Marc is attending a meeting
where all might get together (for example the American
Psychiatric Association), and graduates are always invited to
attend AMSP meetings (unfortunately, at their own expense).
Marianne Guschwan will attend and participate in the
next meeting scheduled for October 2001 in Hawaii.
We will also continue to look for other opportunities
to maintain close working relationships.
Chris Welsh then offered his lecture
on
@ Substance Use Disorders in Health Care Professionals.@
This is a successful lecture that with only a modest
amount of work will be a very useful addition to the website.
Marcy and Marc then presented the
attending Senior Scholars with their graduation plaque,
along with warm wishes and the hope that everyone will have
the chance to maintain close contact.
Lauren Williams next updated the group
on her activities over the prior six months at the University
of Miami. Immediately following the
prior meeting, Lauren went to Carl Eisdorfer, her Chair, and
reviewed her plans. Carl facilitated her
contact with the Physicians Recovery Network who, in
conjunction with other staff at the University of Miami, were
planning programs at the medical school
B taking steps to expand these interactions to include
direct contact with medical students.
Lauren also followed through on her plan to begin cataloging
what is being taught about substance use disorders in Miami.
As a result, contact was made with a colleague
interested in addictions, and this led to establishment of an
Addiction Day program for medical students, medical and
psychiatric residents (attendance being mandatory for the
latter) which will involve setting forth information on
alcohol and drug-related issues and the discussion of a panel
made up of prominent department chairs at that university.
The goals and objectives for the education of
physicians in substance use disorders was also instituted as
part of the plans for revisions of the educational program in
the second year of medical school, and Lauren is working with
a student to establish the DOC program.
Over the next six months she hopes to begin a rotation for
one-to-two medical students on the Addiction Unit, develop a
lecture focusing on substance use disorders for the Medical
Student Orientation, and enhance the quality and intensity of
teaching and case presentations on her unit.
The next order of business was a
demonstration of the AMSP lecture,
ADevelopmental Factors in Substance Use and Approaches
to Intervention and Prevention,@
developed by Karen Trocki. This was an
excellent example of the optimal use of slides, and an
emphasis on the importance of looking at psychosocial and
environmental factors as well as biological influences when
dealing with alcohol dependence and other substance use
problems.
An update on progress in the prior six
months at the University of Maryland was next presented by
Chris Welsh. For first-year medical
students, Chris: is working with the person in charge of
medical student education to be certain that substance use
disorders are included; has established procedures for
optimizing the quality of both lecture material and clinical
supervision regarding substance use disorders; worked with a
DOC-like program helping the students enhance their
information on combined pharmacological and psychological
approaches prior to an outreach visit to a Navajo Indian
Reservation; made a television appearance to talk about
inhalants; worked with the students in their outreach
regarding substance use problems at a City Health Fair; and he
has identified a first-year medical students who will help him
in implementing a "substance use problems in the movies"
elective-type program. For second- and
third-year medical students: Chris is participating in the
revision of the medical school program overall, with the aim
of being certain that substance use disorders are represented;
he is working with lecturers in other courses (e.g.,
pharmacology) to be certain that clinical aspects of alcohol
dependence and related problems are appropriately presented;
Chris is increasing the amount of dedicated time on an
addition unit as part of a psychiatry rotation; he is helping
to expand the lecture series related to substance use
disorders as part of the third-year rotation; and he worked
closely with a medical student who is part of a television
documentary series with his role as a discussant regarding the
importance of substance use problems. For
psychiatric residents, he is working to be certain that all
residents have a six-week dedicated block related to an
alcohol and drug treatment program (currently that's only
being done for half of the first-year residents); is striving
to be certain that alcohol dependence and other similar
disorders are appropriately represented as part of the
psychiatric consultation service; and he has developed a new
lecture for fourth-year residents dealing with the
pharmacological and psychological approaches to substance use
disorders. Finally regarding education
within the medical school, Chris is working closely with the
Coordinator of Substance Use Disorders Education at the
University of Maryland, with the probability that he will
be able to take over this position within the next several
years. Chris continues to work with
the community and has delivered two lectures to pain units,
has joined a state-wide task force dealing with problems
related to the drug Ecstacy, and has delivered lectures to the
nursing school and as part of the block of education offered
at the Health Sciences Center regarding HIV-related problems.
Vijay Ramchandani
provided a copy of an update of his accomplishments at Indiana
University.
These include: a
lecture on genetics of complex diseases including alcoholism
added into the Medical Genetics course for second year medical
students, which was developed and given by Tatiana Foroud; a
new lecture on making the diagnosis of dependence and brief
interventions in the chemical dependency rotation for
third-year students; a target for increasing alcohol education
in OB/GYN and Pharmacology; the development of a core‑book
designed to be a source of information for medical students
about alcohol and other drugs, which will form the basis of
material covered throughout the four years in various courses
throughout the curriculum; being recently appointed as
Assistant Scientist and part‑time Assistant Professor in the
Department of Medicine, a move that will allow him to be in an
even better position to influence and enhance the level of
medical education in alcohol and other drugs
The group discussed plans for the next
AMSP meeting which will begin at 6:00 p.m. on Wednesday,
October 17th, at the Kapalua Bay Resort in Maui, Hawaii.
All scholars were reminded that it is very important
that they attend the entire meeting and make plans not to
leave before noon the following Saturday.
It's important to remember that Kapalua Bay is between one
hour and one hour-and-a-half travel from the Maui airport.
The group began to consider potential
dates for the Spring, 2002 meeting.
Tentatively, the meeting will begin on Wednesday, May 1, 2002,
and a number of potential venues are being discussed.
This includes the possibility of meeting south of San
Francisco in Big Sur or in Monterey-Carmel, or situating a
future meeting in London (as all of the new scholars are from
the East Coast, and it may be less costly to hold a meeting in
London than to transport people to the West Coast or to
Hawaii).
Marianne Guschwan shared some thoughts
regarding coordination of future workshops at national and
international meetings. Both she and
Susan Tapert are eager to see the workshop on teaching
techniques on how to give a lecture continue, and it appears
as if future efforts will incorporate current Junior Scholars
including Chris Welsh, Donna Londino, and Lauren Williams, and
that a graduating scholar, Vania Modesto-Lowe, might also
become part of the presentations perhaps at the American
Psychiatric Association meeting as well as the American
Academy of Addiction Psychiatry. Marianne
will proceed with those applications.
Marc then offered suggestions for
effective time management, which included criteria for
setting priorities and making good career decisions.
The final order of business was to turn
the meeting over to Susan Tapert to demonstrate how, once
Power Point slides have been developed, they can be
effectively used in presentations.
Susan allowed Marc Schuckit (affectionately known as
all-thumbs Charley when it comes to computers) to try it out,
and the group concluded that if he can do it, anyone probably
can. Susan reminded us all that the
lecture material that she has developed on producing and
delivering Power Point slides is now part of the website
lecture on How to Deliver a Lecture.
The meeting adjourned with everyone eager
to implement some of the lessons learned, and each of looking
forward to getting together at the subsequent meeting.
Everyone will be contacted by Marcy to establish the
conference call, probably the last week in August or the first
week in September.